• Welcome to The Building Code Forum

    Your premier resource for building code knowledge.

    This forum remains free to the public thanks to the generous support of our Sawhorse Members and Corporate Sponsors. Their contributions help keep this community thriving and accessible.

    Want enhanced access to expert discussions and exclusive features? Learn more about the benefits here.

    Ready to upgrade? Log in and upgrade now.

Phoenix Disability Advocacy Group Floods Attorney General's Office With Complaints

mark handler

SAWHORSE
Joined
Oct 25, 2009
Messages
11,895
Location
So. CA
Phoenix Disability Advocacy Group Floods Attorney General's Office With Complaints
http://kjzz.org/content/373958/phoe...up-floods-attorney-generals-office-complaints

An advocacy group that has come under fire for filing hundreds of lawsuits against Valley businesses has now flooded Arizona Attorney General’s Mark Brnovich's office with complaints.

In essence, it's a political statement, an effort to call out Brnovich, who has taken a hard line on the aggressive tactics used by Advocates for Individuals with Disabilities (AID).

Since the beginning of the year, the local non-profit has sued more than 1,700 businesses for violating the Americans with Disabilities Act. That led Brnovich to intervene recently on behalf of more than a thousand of the defendants.

Brnovich argues, among other things, that AID is "abusing" the judicial system with "frivolous" lawsuits for its own gain. Many of those sued end up paying thousands of dollars to go to court or to settle.

Brnovich also said the group should be coming to his office first with possible violations, rather than immediately suing a business.

This week, AID took him up on that request and delivered twenty boxes of ADA complaints.

"I’ll guarantee that those 9,000 cases are not going to get resolved in months like the cases AID has filed have for the most part been," attorney Jack Wilenchik, who is representing AID, told KJZZ.

"AID has accomplished more in the space of months than the attorney general's office has done in the space of 22, 26 years," he said.

The attorney general receives about 100 complaints a year for possible violations of the Arizonans with Disabilities Act, the state version of the federal law.

But Brnovich's spokesperson Ryan Anderson said they intend to investigate every single one delivered by AID.

"What AID has done is give us 90 years' worth of complaints at once and then started boasting that we can't get them all done fast enough," Anderson said.

Anderson could not give an exact time frame for how long it will take to resolve all of them, but said it will be "all hands on deck" to deal with the deluge of complaints.

“We contact the business and then we get the situation resolved. What AID has accomplished is collecting likely a million dollars off of settlements from businesses over technical signage violations that did not bar anyone's access,” Anderson said.

AID's lawsuits focus on parking lot regulations like the height of a sign or the width of an accessible space.

A judge recently granted the state's motion to consolidate more than a thousand of the lawsuits. Brnovich has said he intends to ask the judge to dismiss the lawsuits.

Meanwhile, AID has asked a panel of appellate judges to transfer the case to another judge and void everything that has happened since late August.
 
AID.org Tasks Attorney General's Office to Investigate Over 9,000 Documented ADA Violators
http://www.digitaljournal.com/pr/3090384

PHOENIX, AZ--(Marketwired - September 30, 2016) - Advocates for Individuals with Disabilities - Foundation ("AID.org") has filed complaints on over 9,000 business locations with the Arizona Attorney General's Office along with supporting and verified evidence documenting their ADA violations.

AID.org has spent nearly $200,000 in preparing and filing these complaints with the AG, in part, to demonstrate the Attorney General's Office's failure to investigate or enforce compliance with the ADA on a large scale for many years. The ADA was enacted in 1990, with various updates being made through 2010. But according to a recent survey conducted by AID, less than 5% of public accommodations in the county are in compliance with the ADA -- just as to external ADA violations

In just a few months, AID.org, without any government funding or resources, has filed nearly 2,000 ADA enforcement cases and has spent nearly $800,000 in its efforts to bring about compliance, with most of those funds going to filing fees to the Arizona Judicial System. As a direct result of AID's efforts, hundreds of violators have agreed to comply with the noted ADA and AzDA violations and have entered into binding and enforceable settlement agreements. Each one contractually guaranteeing in writing to fix their noted ADA violations by agreed upon dates, which AID.org then follows up on to assure they have made the appropriate ADA and AzDA corrections. Additionally, as a result of AID's efforts and the now public awareness of potential legal enforcement actions, thousands of other businesses are taking note and voluntarily complying with the ADA without the need for anyone to file a lawsuit.

Despite assumptions to the contrary, AID's intentions are pure and AID's sole interest is in bringing about ADA compliance, and has NOT "lined its pockets" and is NOT in it for the money...

While ALL of AID's settlements do require timely ADA violation correction guarantees, most settlement agreements also include a negotiated cash component of approximately $3,900 per case to cover legal, filing, operational and further compliance actions, etc. Never $10,000 per case and far less than media sources falsely portray. The reason that it is necessary for AID to receive proceeds as part of settlement is to partially subsidize the costs of bringing and managing widespread ADA enforcement actions. Doing so is very, very costly, and AID does not use any public tax payer's funds to investigate and enforce ADA laws. This is abundantly made clear by the fact that AID always has, currently is and anticipates it will continue to operate at a substantial loss reaching many hundreds of thousands of dollars. It is definitely clear that AID is NOT "enriching itself", "lining its pockets" or "just in it for the money" because AID hasn't and doesn't expect to make a profit. Despite this fact, AID is willing to do whatever it takes to bring about rapid and wide spread ADA Compliance on a national level, regardless of any initial negative perception.

For full (un-redacted information) and to find out more information and how the Attorney General and Tax Payers could end up picking much of AID's enforcement expenses follow this link below.

https://www.dropbox.com/s/rr2nz9idsm72a47/AID Tasks AG to Investigate over 9,000 Violations.pdf?dl=0

Join AID.org's fight against discrimination by becoming a FREE member and/or civil rights activist at www.AID.org/Membership.html.

AID's Attorneys available for comment:

Dennis Wilenchik (602) 606-2810
Peter Strojnik (602) 524-6602

About Advocates for Individuals with Disabilities Foundation ("AID.org")

AID.org, a 501c3 nonprofit company was formed in January 2016 as Civil Rights Champions in order to improve the lives of individuals with disabilities through charitable gifts, opportunities and the removal of equal access barriers for the over 43 million Americans who live with disabilities caused by one or more conditions.

AID.org sends warning notices to businesses and then acts as private attorneys general to ensure ADA compliance. AID.org's focus is on the most readily visible exterior equal access barriers which Federal, State and Attorney Generals have failed to enforce over the last 26 years. AID.org feels that these violations are a clear indicator of interior ADA violations, which we hope the violating business voluntarily correct.

"For the ADA to yield its promise of equal access for the disabled, it may indeed be necessary and desirable for committed individuals to bring serial litigation advancing the time when public accommodations will be compliant with the ADA." AID.org is committed to bring serial litigation and is primarily self-funded though litigation settlement agreements and private funding.

Those with disabilities and their associates can request assistance and grants online at www.AID.org. To schedule an interview with the AID.org Foundation, please email media@AID.org.

AID.org Foundation Public Relations
Advocates for Individuals with Disabilities Foundation
media@AID.org
 
Back
Top