• Welcome to The Building Code Forum

    Your premier resource for building code knowledge.

    This forum remains free to the public thanks to the generous support of our Sawhorse Members and Corporate Sponsors. Their contributions help keep this community thriving and accessible.

    Want enhanced access to expert discussions and exclusive features? Learn more about the benefits here.

    Ready to upgrade? Log in and upgrade now.

Snow day.. and I need some help

TimNY

REGISTERED
Joined
Jan 13, 2010
Messages
1,133
Location
Charleston, SC
Those of you who have followed my posts have probably realized I'm pretty disappointed in the quality of design and construction in my area. I see many of the same violations that jar sees; the difference being PA just got a building code and NY has been using I-Code derivatives for nearly a decade.

I have the day off due to snow emergency, so I am trying to finish off a project I've been working on.

Rather than continue to complain (ok, in addition to complaining. My secretary will not vouch for my lack of complaining), I've been working on a presentation for about 6 weeks that will be offered to locally licensed contractors. Upon it's approval by the licensing authority, it will hopefully be 6 hours of continuing education. It will satisfy the continuing ed requirements for those contractors for the year.

If that goes well, the plan is to submit to the State and hopefully get approval as continuing ed for NYS inspectors. NYS is pretty tough on giving out continuing ed credits, so I'll burn that bridge when I cross it.

I'm about to wrap up the presentation with ~180 powerpoint slides. I've created it based on the following:

1. It is layed out in the logical progression of home construction-- foundation, framing, plumbing, electrical, insulation, final.

2. It addresses the construction methods and materials commonly used in my area-- PC foundations, stick-built framing (vs trusses etc) microlams and powerbeams (vs parallams, sawn lumber built-up beams and steel), simpson straps, PVC DWV, pex supply etc

3. It addresses the violations I see day after day.. improper venting, improper support/drilling/notching (with emphasis on engineered beams), improper application of wind-resisting techniques (braced walls, strapping etc).

Of course, we've all been in those boring powerpoint presentations with slide after slide of blah blah blah.

The course will be attended by GC, plumbers, electricians, painters and so on, so I have to make the plumbing kind of interesting for the electricians etc. I've made some provisions for this.. such as going over drilling and notching in the plumbing part, which will be useful to the electricians.

I've assembled a pretty good collection of photos to demonstrate a lot of the issues. I find that I am missing a couple that I would really like, so I'm asking if any of you have any photos you took that you would be willing to donate to the cause.

Specifically, I need:

1. Vent connection below the weir of the trap

2. S-trap.. preferably in a pedestal sink which is where I typically see them

3. Anything electrical and basic. Nothing too technical; more like a plumbing pipe running across a panel, an inaccessible disconnect, too many conductors through a bored hole or connector. Something everybody can understand. I don't do electrical inspections, so these are usually covered by insulation when I get there.

4. Anything wind related and basic. I have a lot of photos on this, but it is an important subject and I can always use more.

5. Anything else that is simple to understand.

6. Anything funny (got to have those moments to break up the boring presenter blah blah blah)

If you can help, please make sure they are your photos or you have permission to give them to me. You can post them here or send me a PM with a link.

I don't think I will put the powerpoint file online, but I do plan on recording the presentation and I will make that available for viewing. I will not be paid for the course (in fact, I will have to take a day off from work). I will most likely charge something like $5 to cover reproduction costs and coffee.

TIA,

Tim
 
A few I had handy...

View attachment 330

View attachment 331

View attachment 332

View attachment 333

View attachment 330

View attachment 331

View attachment 332

View attachment 333

/monthly_2011_01/572953bcb66ee_DrainPipebehinddisconnect.jpg.65a9fc49d131c6a686bb4386bfe6338d.jpg

/monthly_2010_10/572953bcb9455_Outriggertooclosetotrench1.jpg.eb5eca7c8a2daddb32377e8236346711.jpg

/monthly_2011_01/572953bcbcc20_ZipTapeVanWindow.jpg.959a7cfb04ad18d39ee389e871fac484.jpg

/monthly_2010_12/572953bcc1f6b_SunkenAnchor.jpg.e9d1158b1026ddd709f79ebb1c87bed8.jpg
 
Thanks so much!

That TJI is great, we use a lot of them here-- not sure to put it in the framing section or the wind resistance section?? Gutter.. classic. Also the countersunk anchor bolt is common with modular homes.
 
* * * *

Tim,

Are the GC's, ...plumbers, ...electricians, ...painters, ...HVAC trades,

etc., in NYS "REQUIRED" to obtain CEU's / continuing ed.?....Also,

do any of those listed actually own / use a code book?

* * * *
 
north star said:
* * * *Tim,

Are the GC's, ...plumbers, ...electricians, ...painters, ...HVAC trades,

etc., in NYS "REQUIRED" to obtain CEU's / continuing ed.?....Also,

do any of those listed actually own / use a code book?

* * * *
They are not required to do so by the State. Plumber and electricians are licensed by the county; I am not sure if the county requires continuing ed.

The local municipality requires a "home improvement license" to work within it's boundaries. Contractors must submit proof of 6 hours of continuing ed to renew their license. If they do not, they may not do any work within the jurisdiction.
 
True you can get some big holes in there. The flanges are 1-1/8" deep, so with a 6" tall hole you should have 1-1/4" (total) web remaining top & bottom. I also note they overcut the top right, you can see the saw mark in the top flange.

Good for discussion tho, because it looks totally non-compliant, but is actually very close (given the loading is correct)
 
TimNY:

The fact that there is a need goes without saying. The fact that you should have any trouble getting it approved is pretty hard to imagine too, if you are any good at what you do. THERE IS A NEED, and it should be mandatory.

At $5 a head, you are way undervaluing your service and experience; again, if you are any good..... You divide your lost days wages, plus coffee service, room rental, copying, etc. etc. by 15 or 20 people, and that’s their cost for attending. And, that same cost should come back to bite them as a service fee or fine, the next time someone who did or should have attending gets red flagged for shooting a bull that you covered in the class in that JHA. Your own JHA should welcome your effort, during a paid day, realizing that it will save them plan checking and return inspection time and costs, if it’s done right the first time.
 
Well, the "not getting paid" thing was probably misleading; I would take a comp day so my paycheck would be the same. So, I am using the time I earned, which is somewhat of an "expense", but I'm not really losing dollars.

I really just want to get some training out there. In the end it benefits me, because it should make my job easier. I enjoy teaching (I also help teach fire prevention), so at this point I am happy to do what I can.

Class will be local, so my only out-of-pocket will be a can of coffee, some milk, and the cost of reproducing 100 pages or so per attendee. I am just looking to break even with my out-of-pocket expenses.

I do echo your sentiment about making mistakes that are covered in the class..
 
I hope that 180 slides is enough. I put together a building construction class for the fire department of 155 slides and lasted about 2.5 hours. The presentation all depends on how much discussion you get during the presentation. Goood luck and maybe we can all take a look when it is done.
 
Yeah already thought about that and I'm going to put together a second ppt on alterations and additions. If we have time I'll go into that.

I am hoping for some discussion.. But I know how it usually goes.. question asked by presenter.. deafening silence.. next slide..

If that's not enough I'll just start lecturing on attic access..
 
Here's some of mine. I have hundreds more.....if you want I'll upload them to a web site and you can go there and pick and chose what you want. Some are hard to tell what they are because of the mass of building materials.Let me know.Oh and I taught an 7 hour class with about 200 pictures and just barely made it through the class. I had to encourage conversation.

View attachment 335

View attachment 336

View attachment 337

View attachment 338

View attachment 339

View attachment 335

View attachment 336

View attachment 337

View attachment 338

View attachment 339

/monthly_2011_01/PanelBox2.jpg.d54d87f80c06cd47a8fa20ee153ecc8b.jpg

/monthly_2011_01/572953bcdde3f_10048RegentRowWaterinMeterBase3.jpg.b0f0d0e4773c7b792d98ffe400cabd7e.jpg

/monthly_2011_01/PanelBox1.jpg.b133fd752dc86ba59e76bd3a46b63b41.jpg

/monthly_2011_01/572953bceba4d_10048RegentRowWaterinMeterBase2.jpg.1571952f77e341c1e793dca5799cf7ba.jpg

/monthly_2011_01/572953bcf1e54_Halloween09006.jpg.083fe7dc1fc231d81066ad2952642c6e.jpg
 
You probably don't need more slides for 6 hours.. you need to speak to each violation and encourage dialog regarding them... ask questions and make someone respond.. even if you stand like a statue for a minute.
 
peach that is really what I'm going for. I read an article on powerpoints a while ago and how they were ruining learning because it was just click..click..click.. and there was no interaction.

A lot of the slides are just a code section in plain english with a reference. I am all about "why". So while the slide may not say much, there will be my personal interjection on why it says that.

I hope I get (and I believe I will) some "that's crazy", "that's just stupid", "yeah, right". Honestly I agree with some of it but I hope it can lead to some good conversation.

Doing this for the first time it helps to have the slides-per-hour comparisons. I wasn't really sure.. I figured 2 min per slide average. Some might be 30 secs but others 5 mins.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Don't overload your presentation with slides that don't really "say" anything.. Explain the violation and ask for the feedback.

Know your audience: are they there just for the CEU's or do they really want to take at least one thing away from the class? That should really be the goal.. take ONE thing away that you didn't know before.. if you say that upfront, they'll pay more attention.. they don't know what they don't know.

If they are just there for the CEU's, you'll be talking to a bunch of heads of lettuce "I'm here because I need the CEU's". If they attend, they get the CEU's...

separate the wheat from the chaff before you start the class.. that's all I'm saying.

Keep it interesting.
 
Oh, hey.. btw.. give aways are also good.

I did a construction safety class for a NARI group a couple of years back; I knew the audience was going to include some certified lead carpenters who were doing good or bad and used those photos.. those guys each got these cool scales we use as marketing tools after I showed the picture.. everyone got a mechanical pencil with our company information on them.

Having a "prize" encourages participation.

Oh, and, hey.. don't stand in front of the podium.. use a wireless device, and engage the audience by walking around and asking questions to the prisoners.. oh.. I mean participants.
 
Talking to a bunch of heads of lettuce. Now there is a visual you can use instead of the old "picture them in their underwear". The prize for participation is something I am going to try next time. Our area meets each month, approx. 20-25 inspectors, to discuss code issues. Friday morning and last 3.5 hours. No CEU's, just guys trying to do better (and get out of the office). I will try this approach on them and see how much enthusiasm it generates. Don't overload the presentation with text and just read the slides, that always annoyed me when sitting in the audience. Follow text slides with picture of example to generate the discussion. You might consider tossing in a slide that is totally and obviously incorrect and see if they catch it. If not, cultivate the lettuce and have salad. (That still cracks me up)
 
Up to 197 slides now.. Still need photos if you got any you can share

Would particularly like:

-vent connection below weir of trap

-basic electrical (would like pic of ufer)

-energy code related

Tried converting to swf for web viewing.. lost all the animations..

TIA,

Tim
 
Still working on this.. Still looking for a pic with a fixture arm connected to a wye, or I'll take any "connection to the vent stack below the weir of the trap" photo.

Also learned a few things..

1. I moved from MS Powerpoint to OpenOffice Impress. The show imported almost perfectly. I lost my sounds and my motion path were screwed up, but overall it wasn't too bad. While you can get a powerpoint viewer, I found I needed more flexibility than editing on the desktop and just viewing on the laptop. Impress is free so I installed the full version on all computers and can edit everywhere. Nice.

2. Know the difference between linking photos and embedding photos. Normally the problem is you don't embed them.. when you go to use the presentation on another computer, the photos are missing. In my case they were all embedded.. then I found everything was slow because the presentation was 150 megs... I didn't resize the photos prior to embedding. So I had to delete each embedded photo and embed a resized version. What a PITA! But, the presentation is <50 megs now.. much faster :)

Also still looking for some basic electrical photos... TIA
 
WEATHER ALERT - Southern California could be sunned-in for the next several days. Residents have been urged to hunker down at their nearest beach or tiki bar for further instructions. Use extreme caution when braving this blizzard of sunshine, preferably 30 SPF. We're asking our friends and relatives to the East to please keep us in their thoughts as we deal with our 2 feet buried in the sand.
 
This is one of my favorites, violation of 314.29 at the very least.

Before Chris;

BainJBox001.jpg


After Chris;

BainJBox002.jpg
 
Hand holes

The first two here show violations of 314.30, 314.30©, and 314.30(D). BTW, took an hour for me to find this as I never thought to look in a clean-out.

DSCN1993.jpg


DSCN1992.jpg


This next one show the proper way to be 314.30© compliant, Polaris Blue.

DSCN0910.jpg
 
Back
Top