A recent Type I was done by an HVAC guy, no experience in Type I work, but he was cheap. The red silicone was visible, except where they used silver spray paint to hide the silicone. But, some red silicone was visible at the upper reaches of the duct. Both inspectors, the onwer's rep and I went on the roof to look at the silicone. We pulled the exhaust fan off, no hinge kit and no cover on the grease tray. The silicone was visible and the job was failed. The contractor called the inspector and asked why the job failed. The inspector explained the code issues, but did allow the contractor to cut a piece of the welded seam out. It was welded, and the inspector passed the job. Now everyone is happy. And at the first service, I will install a hinge kit on the fan.
I like working with that inspector, he is open to suggestions and is willing to work with us.