• Welcome to the new and improved Building Code Forum. We appreciate you being here and hope that you are getting the information that you need concerning all codes of the building trades. This is a free forum to the public due to the generosity of the Sawhorses, Corporate Supporters and Supporters who have upgraded their accounts. If you would like to have improved access to the forum please upgrade to Sawhorse by first logging in then clicking here: Upgrades

Accessibler Bar Seating

J

Jmb

Registered User
Joined
May 16, 2016
Messages
40
Location
PA
I have a question concerning accessible dining seating.

Code references: IBC 2015, ICC/ANSI A117.1-2009.

A2 Restaurant Occupancy with a dining area separate from a bar area. The concern is the bar.

The architect is proposing an accessible dining portion of the bar that is at 34” AFF to the top, knee and toe clearance under this portion that extends 17” underneath. The general seating bar top height is 3’-6” AFF

When this accessible seating space is needed, there is counter that flips up and wings that hinge out to supports this accessible seating countertop, then a section of the 3’-6” high bar top is removed (lifted out) if front of this accessible space.

I would think that this accessible portion should be available at all times, so the flip up top may not comply. Also, a disabled person should be able to use a facility and element independently, so to lift the flip up portion, if permitted, should not require more than 5 pounds of pressure and no tight pinching or grasping to do so. The removable 3’-6” bar top could stay in place since there is no requirement for full depth of a countertop for a dining seat other than depth of toe clearance


Any thoughts would be helpful, thanks!
 
You cannot "displace" a Disabled person to gain access to back of bar.
If there is another way into the "back of bar?
 
mark handler said:
You cannot "displace" a Disabled person to gain access to back of bar.
If there is another way into the "back of bar?
Click to expand...

No sure what you mean Mark, the disabled customer wouldn't need to get to the back of the bar. The flip up dining countertop is on the public side of the bar.
 
So how about a disabled bartender in a wheel chair??

Do they have to lower the bar, and bar equipment
 
Jmb said:
No sure what you mean Mark, the disabled customer wouldn't need to get to the back of the bar. The flip up dining countertop is on the public side of the bar.
Click to expand...
You cannot displace a "PATRON" so that workers can access the Back of bar area.
 
mark handler said:
You cannot displace a "PATRON" so that workers can access the Back of bar area.
Click to expand...

Mark, this accessible bar portion is not located at an employee opening to the rear of the bar. It is located at a general public seating area at the bar. If there were patrons seated in this location at the 3'-6" bar top, they would have to move to allow for this accessible flip up counter to be opened
 
Jmb said:
Mark, this accessible bar portion is not located at an employee opening to the rear of the bar. It is located at a general public seating area at the bar. If there were patrons seated in this location at the 3'-6" bar top, they would have to move to allow for this accessible flip up counter to be opened
Click to expand...
Not kosher
 
I would not allow this. It must be a permanent accessible counter or bar top because the non-accessible top is permanent. Otherwise they could just use a folding table.

I won't allow fold-ups for service counters too. Or movable parking signs.
 
Another question about bar seating. If I have a total length of bartop that is only 8'-0" long, does 5' of it need to be at accessible height for disabled patron and companion seating?
 
by whose choice was it only chosen to be 8'?

Offer table service only and consider it a service bar.
 
JPohling said:
Another question about bar seating. If I have a total length of bartop that is only 8'-0" long, does 5' of it need to be at accessible height for disabled patron and companion seating?
Click to expand...
You are correct if the entire bar is only 8' however if that's the case the bar is going to have other problems. In that case the best resolution would probably be to make the entire bar at accessible height and let people share it or as suggested by another poster just called a service bar and just have table seating.
 
If (2) types of bar service are offered patrons must be able to choose either. Both must have accessible provisions.
 
^If that's true, it is not being enforced in most jurisdictions in Ohio. Not sure I've ever seen a 34" bar, though I'll be looking for them starting now.

What defines a service bar? It doesn't have fixed stools? Or is it how the bar is managed and beverages sold?

When I look at ADAAG 5.2 "Where food or drink is served at counters exceeding 34" for consumption by customers seated on stools or standing at the counter, a portion of the main counter which is 60" in length min shall be provided or service shall be available at accessible tables within the same area"

Seems like tables are acceptable
 
If an ambulatory person can be served at a choice of either a table or a bar, so too must a disabled person have the same choice.
 
Also, when you think about accessible service height at a bar, be careful not to obstruct from the ability to conduct the transaction from the employee's side of the bar, even if the customer still has a 34" high counter for their use. See this article about a similar situation posted by Mark back in 2015:

"A U.S. District Court judge in Santa Ana sided with plaintiff Gilbert Salinas, a paraplegic who filed an ADA complaint after he visited a Corner Bakery Cafe in Long Beach in April 2013. When Salinas approached the 46-inch counter to pay, he discovered it was too high for his use. His wife paid, but Salinas alleges in his lawsuit the experience “was frustrating and somewhat embarrassing".

The restaurant chain contends in court documents that a second, 34-inch counter located on the customer side of the counter does comply with the ADA. The law requires a portion of the counter to be at least 36-inches in length and a maximum height of 36 inches from the floor.

The problem is that employees still have to reach over the higher counter to use the lower, said Mark Potter, a San Diego lawyer who represents Salinas. Potter is the same lawyer who represents another disabled man who uses a wheelchair and is a frequent ADA-plaintiff, Fair Oaks lawyer Scott Johnson.

U.S. District Court Judge Cormac Carney agreed the lower counter meets the requirements, but because the cashier stands behind the higher counter, “all transactions “necessarily occur over that higher counter.” He granted summary judgment to the plaintiff Aug. 31.
 
ADAguy said:
If an ambulatory person can be served at a choice of either a table or a bar, so too must a disabled person have the same choice.
Click to expand...
No I would rather exclude twenty percent of the population from my potential customers...
 
20% of the population needs a 34" counter?

1994 ADA Standards: 5.2 "Where food or drink is served at counters exceeding 34" for consumption by customers seated on stools or standing at the counter, a portion of the main counter which is 60" in length min shall be provided or service shall be available at accessible tables within the same area"

2010 ADA Standards: 226 Dining Surfaces. Where dining surfaces are provided for the consumption of food or drink, at least 5 percent of the seating spaces and standing spaces at the dining surfaces shall comply with 902 (34"h).
 
CityKin said:
20% of the population needs a 34" counter?

1994 ADA Standards: 5.2 "Where food or drink is served at counters exceeding 34" for consumption by customers seated on stools or standing at the counter, a portion of the main counter which is 60" in length min shall be provided or service shall be available at accessible tables within the same area"

2010 ADA Standards: 226 Dining Surfaces. Where dining surfaces are provided for the consumption of food or drink, at least 5 percent of the seating spaces and standing spaces at the dining surfaces shall comply with 902 (34"h).
Click to expand...
No
Approximately 20% of the population has a disability. Approximately 5% are chair users.
But business owners that do not make there businesses accessible are excluding 20 percent of the potential clientele. Some people, not wheelchair users, can not comfortably sit in high top chairs/stools, so they can enjoy the counter/bar with a regular chair at the 34" high bar.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top