GCtony said:
I have a unrelated question but didn't want to start another thread. We have an out of town project, a large retail store. The building inspector has been a "little over the top" with some of his interpertations of the code. We've played nice and done what he's asked. But today one of the things he failed us for on a final was "install 6" cove base in the restrooms" We'll go ahead and change out the 4" to 6" like he asked but I spent an hour looking in the IBC and can't find any requirement for 6" base. Does this exist or is this something he just likes to see?
Thanks in advance.
IBC Chapter 12 (2009 edition) would support your position
SECTION 1210
SURROUNDING MATERIALS
1210.1 Floors and wall base finish materials. In other than
dwelling units, toilet, bathing and shower room floor finish
materials shall have a smooth, hard, nonabsorbent surface. The
intersections of such floors with walls shall have a smooth,
hard, nonabsorbent vertical base that extends upward onto the
walls at least 4 inches (102 mm).
This is a change from 2006 codes which had it at 6".
If you are under the 2006 codes, technically he is correct.
In our jurisidction, we do look to codes that are coming up for adoption and will consider those code changes when considering a request for modification.
If this was my jurisdiction, and you were permitted under the 2006 codes, on a minor (IMHO) issue such as this, we would allow compliance with the newer code.
What code were you permitted under?
One option you always have is to request, in writing, a modification from the building official. You are supposed to provide the compelling evidence that your alternative is equal in safety and such.
Using a code change to a slightly lesser requirement, IMHO, would qualify.
Worth a shot.
Also, I always feel there is nothing wrong with asking inspectors and plans examiners what section of the code is being violated when they issue a notice of correction. Coming from the side of the enforcers of the code, I feel this is an entirely reasonable request. I have instructed my inspetors to, if unable to quote chapter and verse on the spot, inform the contractor that we will provide them a code citation later that day or the following day at the least..
Part of our job as code officers involves education to the public and I fully support that.
Have a nice day. Good luck.