• Welcome to the new and improved Building Code Forum. We appreciate you being here and hope that you are getting the information that you need concerning all codes of the building trades. This is a free forum to the public due to the generosity of the Sawhorses, Corporate Supporters and Supporters who have upgraded their accounts. If you would like to have improved access to the forum please upgrade to Sawhorse by first logging in then clicking here: Upgrades

Building Codes Are Stupid

jar546

jar546

Forum Coordinator
Joined
Oct 16, 2009
Messages
11,069
Location
Somewhere Too Hot & Humid
[h=2]Building Codes Are Stupid...[/h]I recall a conversation with a city fire chief a few years ago, he had a problem recruiting "fire fighters." In his suburban town, the occurrence of home fires was down and this was largely due to the superior construction methods, materials, and codes. As a result, most of the work and training of his staff had very little to do with fires and a lot to do with medical and other emergencies. And, it seems that fighting fires was much more exciting, and a better recruitment tool. What a nice problem to have! There are fewer fires in new construction, and as a result, it is harder to recruit fire fighters. (And, by the way, I wish we had more codes requiring fire sprinkler systems!)

New homes also use much less fuel for heating and cooling; require fewer plumbing repairs; and are less likely to be built in a swamp. And most of that is due to those "stupid" codes. Codes are not fun to follow. They don't often allow for special circumstances or innovative approaches. Codes are slow to change. And yes, codes contain some "stupid" provisions.

Article credited to:

Information and help for your home: | Sound Home Resource Center

 
Not sure if newer homes do not burn, I think that is kind of a myth. Fire does not discriminate.

just like more fires in lower soci areas

Sorry but ems is about 75% of runs in most cities, need to justify the job
 
I think you're right, cda, that fire does not discriminate, but it does seem to pick on the stupider people. The codes are deaf and dumb, but not really stupid. They are just minimums that are in place to try to help protect the stupid ones in society: those who smoke in bed, turn on the stove and walk away to watch soap operas, plug in Christmas tree lights and forget to water the tree and when it catches fire... well, you know. I often wish for the days of the 1997 UBC where the exceptions were for the residential [mostly] and not today's IRC which is more dense and thicker than the IBC. Simpler times are gone. But then, humans have the propensity to make things much more complex than they need to be. Throw out the computers, i-Phones, and other time-sink thieves, and the world might be a better place to inhabit in general. OK, done with the rant. Enjoy the codes. They will change soon enough.
 
I love the codes; there are some provisions I think are dumb and outdated. I'm kind of surprised that FD's in suburban/rural areas even bother.. even in this metro area, most of the suburban areas are mostly VFDs.
 
One code I can't get my mine around is the stair spindle maximum spacing @ 4-3/8" and the guard rail maximum spacing @ 4".

I thought the 4" sphere was in reference to the child's head?

Pc1
 
One code I can't get my mine around is the stair spindle maximum spacing @ 4-3/8" and the guard rail maximum spacing @ 4".

I thought the 4" sphere was in reference to the child's head?

A toddler playing on the steps is more likely to fall down the stairs than through the guardrail.

I wonder why the code doesn't require gates at the top & bottom of all stairs, instead of leaving it up to the parents to install them when there are toddlers around. The code doesn't trust parents to install outlet safety covers.
 
Stop it,

Now, I'm going to have to inspect gates at top and bottom of stairs, sheesh. I miss the old SBCCI; and the wonderful, knowledgeable team they had. When you called they actually knew what you were talking about. And, I concure, you could use the last SBCCI codes and not miss a beat when it comes to good construction practices, without all the other crap that was add since then. However, we got what we got and, unfortunately there is no stopping the ICC book sales corporation.

Uncle Bob
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top