I have reviewed that section. I'm not quite sure I understand it. The only item that would apply in this case is number 2. Does not penetrate a horizontal assembly that separates fire areas or smoke barriers that separate smoke compartments. My understanding: I am penetrating a horizontal assembly (1hr rated floor). Definition of Fire Area: The aggerate floor area enclosed and bounded by fire walls, fire barriers, exterior walls, or horizontal assemblies of a building. So yes I am penetrating a horizontal assembly that separates a fire area. Now does this fire area separate smoke compartments? My understanding is that smoke compartments are required in some cases for ambulatory care, and I2 and I3 uses and for unprotected areas of refuge. Am I reading the wording wrong. Is what it's saying : Does not penetrate a horizontal assembly that separates fire areas or does not penetrate a smoke barrier that separates a smoke compartment? I've read the commentary, and it seems to apply only to I2 and I3, just want to confirm?