• Welcome to The Building Code Forum

    Your premier resource for building code knowledge.

    This forum remains free to the public thanks to the generous support of our Sawhorse Members and Corporate Sponsors. Their contributions help keep this community thriving and accessible.

    Want enhanced access to expert discussions and exclusive features? Learn more about the benefits here.

    Ready to upgrade? Log in and upgrade now.

Composting Toilets

fatboy

fatboy

Administrator
Joined
Oct 17, 2009
Messages
6,887
Location
Northern CO
I was wondering if anyone has dealt with composting toilets. All the codes are completely silent on them, I suppose they most closely resemble a private sewage disposal system, but they are not addressed there. I have a Council person that has had the question asked of her, I've not had it asked before, any thoughts?
 
fatboy said:
I was wondering if anyone has dealt with composting toilets. All the codes are completely silent on them, I suppose they most closely resemble a private sewage disposal system, but they are not addressed there. I have a Council person that has had the question asked of her, I've not had it asked before, any thoughts?
Click to expand...
Not a lot of information out on them but here is a standards document for the process.NSF/ANSI 41-2011

Non-Liquid Saturated Treatment Systems

NSF International / 18-Feb-2011 / 38 pages
 
use them at deer camp! we did not accept them at the county level or the city level. the health dept would not accept them as an alternative to septic systems. In order to obtain a building permit for a house the health dept required a percolation test.
 
+ +

Where are the wastes going to be deposited?..... a

single application, ...multiple, ...etc. ?

+ +
 
Last edited by a moderator:
* $ *

Thought that I would resurrect this topic in an attempt to

obtain / generate some more discussion & information.

Does anyone have experience with the composting toilets

in their jurisdiction, ...mainly in a Commercial setting, ...or

does anyone know of other locations [ i.e. - countries

outside the U.S. ] that successfully use & regulate these

composting / waterless type toilets?.....I have received an

inquiry about the use & viability of them, in a Commercial

application.



* $ *
 
north star, you might want to contact the Wyoming Department of Transportation. I know that they have at least two larger rest stops along Highway 85 that have used composting toilets for the last 10-15 years. It seems to work for them, and that Highway is pretty heavily used.

steveray, our water department needed to install restroom facilities at one of our reservoir pump stations that did not have santiary sewer service, so they installed one of those incinerating toilets. Seemed to work fine for them.
 
+ ^ +



"There are no universally accepted performance standards for composting toilets."
Click to expand...
If there are no universal standards, how do they get installed incertain locations?........Would they be considered the lesser cost

option, say at locations like the remote Roadside Restrooms

scenario, or out of the hiking trails, versus having no

accomodations at all for people to relieve themselves?



+ ^ +
 
http://water.epa.gov/aboutow/owm/upload/2005_07_14_comp.pdf

Maintenance of composting toilet systems requires more responsibility and commitment by users and owners than conventional wastewater systems.

Removing the finished end-product is an unpleasant job if the composting toilet system is not properly installed or maintained.

Composting toilet systems must be used in conjunction with a graywater system in most circumstances.

Smaller units may have limited capacity for accepting peak loads.

Improper maintenance makes cleaning difficult and may lead to health hazards and odor problems.

Using an inadequately treated end-product as a soil amendment may have possible health consequences.

There may be aesthetic issues because the excrement in some systems may be in sight.

Too much liquid residual (leachate) in the composter can disrupt the process if it is not drained and properly managed.

Most composting toilet systems require a power source.

Improperly installed or maintained systems can produce odors and unprocessed material.
 
fatboy said:
I was wondering if anyone has dealt with composting toilets. All the codes are completely silent on them, I suppose they most closely resemble a private sewage disposal system, but they are not addressed there. I have a Council person that has had the question asked of her, I've not had it asked before, any thoughts?
Click to expand...
Not quite all codes are silent.

ICC 700-2008 National Green Building Standard Section 802.2 gives 8 points for each composting or waterless toilet and urinal installed up to a max of 24 points and an additional 8 points if all installed toilets and urinals are waterless.

Cleavus Multrum is a major manufacturer

Clivus Multrum, Inc.: Manufacturer of Composting Toilets and Greywater Systems since 1973

I have used them in backcountry sites and scout camps they have some limitations and are high maintenance--have to add the much or leaves each use and if sanitizing cleaners or bleach is dumped in the toilet you end up with a real stinky mess because it kills the bugs that are doing the composting--big problem at the girl scout camp by well meaning leaders. Some are solar powered for the exuast fan others use a black painted chimney to draw the oders out of the composting chamber via natural ventilation.
 
Frank said:
Not quite all codes are silent. ICC 700-2008 National Green Building Standard Section 802.2 gives 8 points for each composting or waterless toilet and urinal installed up to a max of 24 points and an additional 8 points if all installed toilets and urinals are waterless.

Cleavus Multrum is a major manufacturer

Clivus Multrum, Inc.: Manufacturer of Composting Toilets and Greywater Systems since 1973

I have used them in backcountry sites and scout camps they have some limitations and are high maintenance--have to add the much or leaves each use and if sanitizing cleaners or bleach is dumped in the toilet you end up with a real stinky mess because it kills the bugs that are doing the composting--big problem at the girl scout camp by well meaning leaders. Some are solar powered for the exuast fan others use a black painted chimney to draw the oders out of the composting chamber via natural ventilation.
Click to expand...
The ICC 700-2008 National Green Building Standard, is not a code.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top