• Welcome to The Building Code Forum

    Your premier resource for building code knowledge.

    This forum remains free to the public thanks to the generous support of our Sawhorse Members and Corporate Sponsors. Their contributions help keep this community thriving and accessible.

    Want enhanced access to expert discussions and exclusive features? Learn more about the benefits here.

    Ready to upgrade? Log in and upgrade now.

IBC 2009 1203.4 Natural ventilation

P

pmarx

Bronze Member
Joined
Oct 13, 2010
Messages
118
Can someone please confirm (or deny) that "minimum openable area" (1203.4.1) is the clear area a window will provide in the open postion similar to an emergency escape window (1029.1) which at least uses the words "clear opening"? Thanks.
 
1203.4.1 Is for light and ventilation

1029.1 Is for egress

Unrelated

Similar but not the same

1203.4.1 can include window trim/stop

1029.1 can not
 
Thank you Mark. I realize that the two sections address different issues, I was using the latter for it's specific terminology. "Openable area" is too ambiguous for me to use anything less than the figures I arrived at using the formula the Traco engineer gave me. Maybe that's a worse case than including trims and stops but I'd rather err on the side of caution.
 
The 2009 commentary 1203.4 has a diagram that mentions the glazed area for determining openable area for ventilation.
 
gbhammer said:
The 2009 commentary 1203.4 has a diagram that mentions the glazed area for determining openable area for ventilation.
Click to expand...
Thanks. I can't say I agree with your conclusion about Fig. 1203.4.1 but I asked an associate to fax that page to me and in the commentary it states, "openable area (the net-free area of a door, window, louver, vent or skylight etc., when fully opened."

I still say the code is ambiguous but not including "net-free" as it does in the emergency egress window section.
 
OK, technically the emergency egress window section states "net-clear".
 
pmarx said:
Can someone please confirm (or deny) that "minimum openable area" (1203.4.1) is the clear area a window will provide in the open postion similar to an emergency escape window (1029.1) which at least uses the words "clear opening"? Thanks.
Click to expand...
What is the calculation?

Assume a 10 x 12 room = 120 SF x .04 SF/SF = 4.8 SF required

What size window is proposed? Does it really come down to opening size versus frame size?
 
Most of the spaces are below 120 SF so the proposed windows exceed the 4% minimum requirement. The window unit is a 40"x61" aluminum slider. Per the manufacturer, the formula for the vent area is W/2 - 5-1/4”x H - 6-5/8”. I come up with 5.6 SF. This is fine except for one particular bedroom that is 170 SF (6.8 SF). I’m just trying to justify to the project architect the need to revise some windows.
 
I’m just trying to justify to the project architect the need to revise some windows.
Click to expand...
Or provide the documentation that it meets the mechanical ventilation requirements. Remember they have to meet natural or mechanical but not both.
 
pmarx said:
Most of the spaces are below 120 SF so the proposed windows exceed the 4% minimum requirement. The window unit is a 40"x61" aluminum slider. Per the manufacturer, the formula for the vent area is W/2 - 5-1/4”x H - 6-5/8”. I come up with 5.6 SF. This is fine except for one particular bedroom that is 170 SF (6.8 SF). I’m just trying to justify to the project architect the need to revise some windows.
Click to expand...
Ask the architect for the proposed/required calculations on the questionable window and let him figure out a change is needed.
 
I work for the architect. LOL, trust me, if I was the plan reviewer I wouldn't have done the calcs in the first place.
 
When reviewing net natural vent are i use the glass area and use a reduction factor for screening then let the designer argue back and yes I do check the submissions

get alot of these as most college dorm / frat / apartment designers dont figure it right until we meet, then they get the next one right. Some use combined baths lavs etc as mechanical and live / sleep as natural - thats always fun
 
Architect1281 said:
When reviewing net natural vent are i use the glass area and use a reduction factor for screening then let the designer argue back and yes I do check the submissionsget alot of these as most college dorm / frat / apartment designers dont figure it right until we meet, then they get the next one right. Some use combined baths lavs etc as mechanical and live / sleep as natural - thats always fun
Click to expand...
That's exactly what we're dealing with and the thing is that after they get their CO these windows will ever comply because they will put stops to limit the opening to 12" in width. The window height would have to be almost floor to ceiling and that ain't happening. This project is based on an earlier design that the owner wanted to repeat and the same thing was done there so...*shrug*
 
when did we take mechanical ventilation out? The other issue is the window limiters if the window is >72" above grade and <24" above finished floor. Even if those windows CAN be opened more than a 4" opening, they can't.
 
peach said:
when did we take mechanical ventilation out? The other issue is the window limiters if the window is >72" above grade and <24" above finished floor. Even if those windows CAN be opened more than a 4" opening, they can't.
Click to expand...
Sorry, I didn't follow the point about if the window is greater than 72" above grade plan and less than 24" AFF (the sill?). Is there a code section that requires opening stops? I know the code generally exempts emergency rescue windows below the 4th floor but that means it requires them (with exceptions) from the 3rd floor down. Those 3rd floor windows will be greater than 72" above grade and will have to open to a clear size of 5.7 SF.

I also dispute that the architect has to design to the worst case of what a property owner may do after they get a CO. If those windows are installed as they came from the factory, namely they can be fully open to provide enough ventillation, that's all the architect should be responsible for. So unless someone can correct my ignorance of a requirement for limiting stops I think we're going with the windows as designed.
 
pmarx said:
Sorry, I didn't follow the point about if the window is greater than 72" above grade plan and less than 24" AFF (the sill?). Is there a code section that requires opening stops? I know the code generally exempts emergency rescue windows below the 4th floor but that means it requires them (with exceptions) from the 3rd floor down. Those 3rd floor windows will be greater than 72" above grade and will have to open to a clear size of 5.7 SF.I also dispute that the architect has to design to the worst case of what a property owner may do after they get a CO. If those windows are installed as they came from the factory, namely they can be fully open to provide enough ventillation, that's all the architect should be responsible for. So unless someone can correct my ignorance of a requirement for limiting stops I think we're going with the windows as designed.
Click to expand...
yes, see 612.2
 
If these are dorms rooms then I assume you are designing from the IBC, not the IRC. The appropriate code section for the window openings at 72" or more above grade is Section 1413.2.
 
I really mis the edit button - As a designer I NEVER let the building official dictate the worst Higest most deadly use that could happen. The owner states the intended use and the it is an enforcement / compliance issue. otherwise all uses would be H - now as a CBO thats what I assume when the applicant says use to be determined.
 
Big Mac said:
If these are dorms rooms then I assume you are designing from the IBC, not the IRC. The appropriate code section for the window openings at 72" or more above grade is Section 1413.2.
Click to expand...
Thanks for the citation (but I had to hunt around chapter 14 because it only goes up to 1408). 1405.13.2 answers my question but still doesn't apply in this case as the sills are greater than 24" AFF but I'll be sure to keep this in mind.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top