• Welcome to The Building Code Forum

    Your premier resource for building code knowledge.

    This forum remains free to the public thanks to the generous support of our Sawhorse Members and Corporate Sponsors. Their contributions help keep this community thriving and accessible.

    Want enhanced access to expert discussions and exclusive features? Learn more about the benefits here.

    Ready to upgrade? Log in and upgrade now.

SFR Damage From F3 Tornado

jar546

CBO
Joined
Oct 16, 2009
Messages
12,923
Location
Not where I really want to be
This is a house that is CMU and tie-beams, and constructed to a 170mph wind zone per ASCE-7. It was in the path of an F3 tornado and look the damage it caused.

A stick framed house does not stand a chance.

IMG_1909.jpg
 
What’s the wind speed in an F3? It may or may not be built to code but the code is also not a guarantee of surviving a specific event. It’s a standard assumption of what the building might withstand.
 
ASCE-7 uses ultimate design (700 year) wind speeds. There might be some damage at these speeds but the structure won't totally fail if properly designed and constructed. This would be equivalent to the 130 mph post Andrew design wind speed.
 
I did work on a home on the Jersey shore that got hit hard by both Irene and then Sandy.

House sits about 20ft above sea level I believe high tide with rough seas produces sea spray that hits you in the rear of the yard.

When they were building it I was constantly saying to myself this is definitely way over kill.

2x10 framed exterior walls, 2x8 & 2x6 interior walls and I believe 3/4" plywood sheathing, I can't remember if they used Tyvek or something else over the sheathing. But then they installed storm hidden rollup shutters on every exterior window and door, and then 3-inches off face of framed home tied into the framed home with 12 reinforced concrete block walls all the way up to the roof line with all the reinforcement, rebars, concrete fill, wire between courses, and then stucco.

When Irene hit, they had not damage except plantings

When Sandy hit they lost all the vegetation, exterior fence in the back of the home including the grass and part of the sea wall, and except for water from the flood height in the basement, the rest of the house was pretty much just exterior cosmetics.

The homes along the coast to the north and south that were just wood construction, well were inline with what the OP picture looked like.

There is a reason its called a minimum code, but quality always seems to show why it is quality, and I no longer think they over built the home.

1729252455768.png
1729252562668.png
 
There is a reason its called a minimum code, but quality always seems to show why it is quality, and I no longer think they over built the home.
IMG_20241005_101100_471 - Copy.jpg

Took a few years to build, but kinda think the walls will handle extreme wind.

That's load-bearing stonemasonry, not a fascia, btw.
 
Back
Top