• Welcome to The Building Code Forum

    Your premier resource for building code knowledge.

    This forum remains free to the public thanks to the generous support of our Sawhorse Members and Corporate Sponsors. Their contributions help keep this community thriving and accessible.

    Want enhanced access to expert discussions and exclusive features? Learn more about the benefits here.

    Ready to upgrade? Log in and upgrade now.

Single Stair, Many Questions (NFPA Article)

jar546

CBO
Joined
Oct 16, 2009
Messages
12,819
Location
Not where I really want to be
The push to increase the allowable height of residential buildings with a single exit stairwell illuminates the tangled intersection between safety, housing affordability, building codes, and politics.

By Jesse Roman 06-Aug-2024
NEW: Read the recently released NFPA report detailing the findings from the Single Exit Stair Symposium, held at NFPA this September.

Stephen Smith is a cerebral 36-year-old who lives in a modest apartment on the third floor
of a five-story walkup in Brooklyn. Minutes into our conversation, Smith points out matter-of-factly that the slender brick building has only a single stairwell leading down to the street-level exit.

Typically, the height and number of exit stairwells in a building would be of little note to anyone outside of a building code office. But Smith counts these stats—five stories, one exit stair—as a kind of badge of honor and proof of concept. That’s because it’s primarily from his small apartment that Smith has led a national crusade through his nonprofit, the Center for Building in North America, to convince state governments to allow many thousands more residential buildings with a single exit stair like his to be built across North America.

With the exceptions of New York City, Honolulu, and Seattle, nearly all jurisdictions in the United States enforce codes that feature stricter caps on the height of residential apartment buildings with a single exit stairwell. NFPA 101®, Life Safety Code®, puts the limit at four stories; the International Building Code (IBC) puts it at three. Canada limits such buildings to two stories. In contrast, nearly all of Europe, South America, and Asia allow a single exit stairwell in buildings of at least six stories, with some, including South Korea, Germany, and Switzerland, permitting 20 stories or higher.

The height limitations in the U.S. and Canada have had negative consequences on the nations’ housing stock, .............

Read the full article here: https://www.nfpa.org/en/news-blogs-...l/2024/08/06/The-Single-Exit-Stairwell-Debate
 
Typically, the height and number of exit stairwells in a building would be of little note to anyone outside of a building code office. But Smith counts these stats—five stories, one exit stair—as a kind of badge of honor and proof of concept. That’s because it’s primarily from his small apartment that Smith has led a national crusade through his nonprofit, the Center for Building in North America, to convince state governments to allow many thousands more residential buildings with a single exit stair like his to be built across North America.

It's not in any way "proof of concept." It's proof that any building is safe from fire if a fire hasn't occurred in the building. The only way his third-floor apartment with a single exit stair would be proof of concept would be if the first or second floor broke out in a raging fire at 3:00 a.m. while he was asleep at home, and all the occupants on the third, fourth, and fifth floors were able to escape without injury. Then it might be "proof of concept."
 
His five-story walkup was probably built more than a century ago. I have a 1922 edition of the National Board of Fire Underwriters recommended Building Code, and it requires 2 means of exit for residential buildings over 3 stories. In cities it was common to have one interior stair and an exterior fire escape.
 
I'm just curious if the opposition to single stairs serving more than 3 or 4 stories is regardless of construction type and/or fire sprinklers? It does seem the examples in other countries are often masonry buildings through and through.
 
Our wonderful legislators are probably going to get this through. It passed the senate and now in the house.


1741389963217.png
Now what does the code require?
Full NFPA 13 system
Probably a Fire Pump
2 Hour rating for the stair
90 minute doors.
Type I construction if over 6 stories
Type II, III, or IV for 5 stories.

I will bet the state building codes division will cave and amend some of the above mentioned code requirements.
I used to think I would leave when they would nail the coffin shut, not anymore.
 
Now what does the code require?
Full NFPA 13 system
Probably a Fire Pump
2 Hour rating for the stair
90 minute doors.
Type I construction if over 6 stories
Type II, III, or IV for 5 stories.


I will bet the state building codes division will cave and amend some of the above mentioned code requirements.
I used to think I would leave when they would nail the coffin shut, not anymore.

Okay, construction type II, III, or IV for up to 5 stories. Type I for over 6 stories.

What construction type for 6 stories?
 
Back
Top